The top four reasons people remove pools

By Alice Richard
Monday, 14 August, 2017

The top four reasons people remove pools

Business might be booming for pool builders, but pool removal companies have seen a significant increase in pool owners ripping out their backyard pools in recent years. What’s behind peoples’ decisions to remove their pools?

We spoke to two pool removals experts about their typical client profile, and their clients’ reasons for removing pools.

1. Disgruntled former pool owners

Former pool owners who buy a new property with a pool tend to fall into two camps: they either can’t wait to get into their new pool or they can’t wait to get rid of it.

For people who’ve previously found pool ownership a drag due to poor design, inefficient equipment or lack of knowledge, even the most state-of-the-art pool still brings back bad memories.

An older pool in a property can put potential buyers off. Tom Burns of Reverse Pools gets plenty of work from real estate agents who engage him to remove the pool prior to the property being listed for sale.

Also, the great Australian dream is changing and it doesn’t always include a backyard pool, says Burns.

“Many Asian clients don’t want pools. With some clients, if a house settles on the 13th, they want to know what time you can be there on the 14th to remove the pool,” he said.

2. Empty nesters

If the kids moved out long ago and the grandkids don’t visit often, older pool owners can find the prospect of maintaining a pool daunting, from both a financial and physical point of view, according to Lee Cousins of Water Wise Constructions.

In addition, as retirees live longer and have bigger nest eggs, travel is increasingly on the agenda. Not surprisingly, paying to maintain a pool year-round when they’re rarely home doesn’t appeal to many grey nomads.

Before: the pool takes up most of the backyard.After: the family now has an expanse of lawn.

Before and after photos of a pool removal job. Images courtesy of Water Wise Constructions.

3. People who want more backyard

In the bad old days of pool design, a pool was generally shoved in the middle of the backyard, with scant regard for how the space might be best used. For families with young children and pets, a pool takes up valuable real estate that could be better used for kicking a football, playing fetch with the dog or for equipment like trampolines and cubby houses.

Particularly in the southern states, the swimming season is only a few short months (for an unheated pool), but a yard can be used 12 months of the year.

4. Parents of small children

After the horror summer of drownings Australia experienced over the 2016–17 season, many parents of toddlers are beginning to see their backyard pool as a safety hazard rather than a relaxing oasis.

It’s a sad (and scary) fact that children aged zero to four are the most at risk of drowning, and all it can take is a moment’s distraction for a toddler to access a pool and drown.

Parents whose children have had near-drowning incidents often aren’t willing to take the chance again. Cousins says he has been called to remove pools the very next day after a child has nearly drowned. “They get scared and nothing can convince them to keep their pool,” he said.

Before: the pool was unused and needed renovation. After: the pool has been replaced with a 30,000 L water tank with an entertaining area on top.

This pool has been replaced with a 30,000 L water tank with an entertaining area on top. Images courtesy of Water Wise Constructions.

Other factors

Cost: If someone is sitting on the fence, struggling to decide between renovation and removal, cost is usually the deciding factor — it’s much cheaper to remove a pool than renovate it, Burns said.

Changes to fencing laws: Bringing a pool fence up to the applicable standard can be expensive, near impossible or both. In this case, people sometimes opt to remove the pool altogether rather than pay to fence an ageing pool that’s rarely used.

Pool site: If a pool is poorly situated to begin with, a renovation might involve removing the original pool altogether and resiting the new pool somewhere in the backyard that optimises the use of space, Burns said. The owners figure that if they’re going to renovate the pool, they might as well put it where they want it.

Landscaping isn’t cheap: Even if you renovate an older pool, the landscaping tends to be of the same vintage and so will need to be updated. The landscaping renovation can often cost more than the pool renovation itself. When faced with this prospect, many pool owners opt to remove the pool and put the money they would’ve spent on pool renovation into landscape design.

Before: the pool before removal. After: an artist's impression of an entertaining area on the site of the old pool.

Before: the original pool. After: an artist's impression of an entertaining area on the site of the old pool. Images courtesy of Water Wise Constructions.

Energy costs: A pool’s running costs are generally not a determining factor, Burns said. However, he has clients who have calculated down to the dollar how much each swim cost them in the last swim season. A client who didn’t swim often and had inefficient older equipment claims he was paying up to $1500 a swim!

The great unknown: While the cost of energy isn’t the main reason most people remove pools, it is a great unknown — and it seems the only way it’s going is up. A pool owner might manage to run a pool at current energy prices, but a big hike in the cost could tip their pool into the ‘not in the budget’ category.

Adding value: The pool site needn’t be an expanse of lawn — although it often is. Water Wise Constructions converts existing swimming pool sites into underground rainwater storage tanks or sunken lounges with fire pits that enhance clients’ lifestyles.

Everyone’s a winner

Pool removals might be on the rise, but as one of our readers pointed out, every pool that’s removed means a backyard with room for another pool when the homeowner moves on — which mean more business for everyone, whether they’re building or removing pools!

Main image courtesy of Water Wise Constructions.

Related Articles

Choosing the right tile adhesive

Standards are useful starting points for determining the suitability of a tile adhesive, but...

Licensing lessons

What can we learn from the prolonged passage towards legislation of licensing for pool...

Power tools and hearing loss

Industrial noise is an unavoidable part of the building sector and tradies are being urged to...

  • All content Copyright © 2021 Westwick-Farrow Pty Ltd